Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through one, Glow In My Own Way may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes what I write. More on that.
Her name does not matter here so much as the way she did her eyes every morning, fast, three strokes of mascara and nothing else, and somehow it looked finished in a way my full routine never quite managed. We shared a dorm room sophomore year, two narrow beds and one mirror bolted to the back of the closet door, and I watched her get ready most mornings while I was still deciding what to do with my own face.
I asked her what mascara she used within the first two weeks. She told me, generously, even let me try hers a few times before I bought my own. I remember thinking that if I just used the same one, did the same three strokes, I would end up with the same result. That is not how any of this works, obviously, in the way I can say now with distance, but at nineteen it felt like a completely reasonable theory.
What her eyes had that mine did not
Her lashes were naturally long and slightly curled already, so the mascara was doing very little work, mostly just adding a bit of definition to something already there. My lashes are straight and a little sparse near the outer corner, and three strokes of the same product left them looking clumped rather than curled, definitely there but not doing what hers did. I did not understand this at the time. I just assumed I was doing the strokes wrong, applying it at the wrong angle, not blinking correctly, whatever explanation kept the theory intact.
So I practiced. For a whole semester, most mornings, I stood at that closet door mirror after she left for her early class and tried to recreate her three strokes on my own eyes, using her leftover technique and eventually my own tube of the same brand. I got better at applying mascara in general. I did not get her eyes, because they were never going to be available to me, not through practice, not through the same product, not through anything.
I kept thinking the technique was the missing piece. The missing piece was that we had different eyes entirely.
The morning I actually looked
It took an ordinary Tuesday in November, both of us running late, both of us at the mirror at the same time for once, elbow to elbow, doing our own three strokes side by side. I watched her finish in about eight seconds and step back looking done. I was still working on my second eye, and when I finally stepped back next to her, I saw it plainly for maybe the first time. Not a technique gap. An entirely different set of lashes, curling a different direction, catching the light differently, needing a different amount of product to look finished rather than clumped.
I do not know why that particular morning was the one that made it click when so many others had not. Maybe it was just seeing us side by side instead of remembering her face from across the room after she had already left. Something about the two reflections next to each other made the difference undeniable in a way that trying to copy her alone every morning never had.
What I changed after that
I stopped trying to get her eight second result out of my own straighter lashes. I bought a curler, which she never needed and I genuinely did, and I found that curling first and then applying far less product, just the very tips, kept my lashes from clumping the way three full strokes always had. It took me longer than her routine, closer to a full minute than eight seconds, and it looked like my own eyes rather than a slightly worse copy of hers.
- I asked her, honestly, what her actual lashes looked like bare, instead of just copying the finished result.
- I bought a curler instead of more mascara, which was the part I actually needed.
- I stopped timing myself against her eight seconds, since a full minute for a different set of lashes is not slower, it is just different.
Two different faces in one small mirror
We are not roommates anymore, have not been for a long time, but I still think about that closet door mirror sometimes when I am getting ready somewhere unfamiliar. There is something useful in that memory, the two of us elbow to elbow, so clearly not seeing the same face reflected back even though we were looking in the exact same glass. It was never really about the mascara. It was about learning to actually look at what was in front of me instead of what I had decided should be there.
We still talk sometimes, mostly small messages around holidays, and a few years ago she mentioned in one of them that she had started curling her lashes too, for a different reason entirely, nothing to do with me or that dorm room. I laughed reading it, alone in my apartment, because it felt like a strange small proof that neither of us had ever really needed to copy the other. We had just been two people getting ready in the same mirror at the same hour, each with our own version of the work to do.
I think about that semester now less as a mistake and more as the slow, ordinary way most of us learn what our own face actually needs. I did not arrive at the curler by reading about it somewhere or asking an expert. I arrived at it by failing to become someone else for long enough that the failure finally told me something true. That feels like most of what I know about my own face now, less a set of rules I found in one place and more a pile of small mornings where I tried a thing that belonged to somebody else and it did not fit, until eventually I stopped expecting it to.
